anyone use "human wave" orders?

[NewSocialistMan]

I have going ape since they came out with CMBB, but have never used the Human Wave order. Anyone had good results with this?

[Berlichtingen]

I have good results with it whenever I use it (any time I have Green or Conscript troops). Learn the holy trinity (mass, short distances and suppression) and your meek will inherit the earth

[Alkiviadis]

Definately.
as above with plenty of support fire.
50 meters

[Chad Harrison]

At first I thought it would work under fire. It doesnt. Lots and lots of suppresion fire because it only takes one lone squad or HQ to open up at close range and you troops will either be dead or paniced.

Chad

[Coffin 'Enry]

I agree that getting close and heavy supression are necessary for the human wave to work. But if you have them supressed that much and are that close what benefit is there to the human wave?

After the demo I have never used it.

Cheers

[Berlichtingen]

Originally posted by Coffin 'Enry:
what benefit is there to the human wave?The morale boost

[White Phosphorus]

I use it when running across small open distances, when I want to minimize my time of exposure. If there were almost no fire coming in, I'd simply use run, but if there is a possibility of a machinegun firing a burst, then I use human wave. Although I do prefer run to human wave, because of the smaller command delay and none of that brisk walk crap.

[Frunze]

Also useful in snow, where advance can be too tiring.

[DrAlimantado]

Hmm ... I use it slightly differently. On occasion I have issued human wave orders in order force my opponent to concentrate his assets on my low-quality marching troops. The gain is that I can then move up some other assets rather undisturbed and put them in a good position without being harrased by opposing fire.

For example: I recently played a game where I had no vehicles left and all infantery close to the main flag was supressed by my opponent's three Stummels. I had two ATR's on the other side of the map and needed to move them into LOS of the Stummels. Said and done I ordered my suppressed troops to human wave up to the Stummels, while I ordered my ATR's to move into a good position. My opponent had no real option but to stand firm and deal with my human wave. He did it well, but was later on shot by my ATRs. Was it worth it? Yeah, I had fresh reserve infantry which could move up after the Stummels were killed.

M

[Coffin 'Enry]

Originally posted by Berlichtingen:
</font><blockquote>quote:</font><hr />Originally posted by Coffin 'Enry:
what benefit is there to the human wave?The morale boost</font>[/QUOTE]I hadn't thought of that and to be honest haven't noticed its lack, but you are right. I must experiment more.

Thanks.

[CRSutton]

Pick your time. Human waves are good for blowing out a depleted and hurting enemy. Against fresh troops with plenty of ammo, you can expect to die a lot. Pretty much on the money historically.

[Aco4bn187inf]

What's that scenario in which the Russians have to attack some German infantry dug in alongside a river? It's an all-infantry small scenario on the disk but I forget the name. Anyway, my friend, a complete novice, simply gave all the Russian infantry the human wave command, and he had a total success. The benefit was that the Russian infantry arrived on top of the germans all at the same time, perhaps the only possible way to deal with the HMGs. This was especially good since that scenario is only about 10 turns long, as I recall. There was no time to scout, fire and maneuver, formulate clever plans, or whatever.

[JasonC]

I use it not to bayonet charge right on top of defenders, but to cross open areas well short of them. I aim to get to cover 100-150 yards from defenders. Once there I just shoot it out, only advancing the rest of the way when the defenders are pinned or running away.

It is much faster than "advance" a few squads at a time. It does leave a residue of broken guys behind, but company HQs can pick those up and get most of them back into the fight eventually.